2 Samuel 1:16

16 "You asked for it," David told him. "You sealed your death sentence when you said you killed God's anointed king."

2 Samuel 1:16 Meaning and Commentary

2 Samuel 1:16

And David said unto him, thy blood [be] upon thy head
The blood that he had shed, let him suffer for it; for as he had shed blood, his blood ought to be shed, according to the law of God; and for proof of this, that he had so done, he appeals to his own confession:

for thy mouth hath testified against thee, saying, I have slain the
Lord's anointed;
and what might serve to confirm the truth of what he had said were the crown and bracelet which he brought along with him; and besides he was an Amalekite, of a nation that was devoted to destruction; and, as Abarbinel thinks, David might suppose that he killed Saul to take vengeance on him for what he had done to their nation; but, after all, both he and Maimonides F14 allow the punishment of him was not strictly according to law, but was a temporary decree, an extraordinary case, and an act of royal authority; for in common cases a man was not to be condemned and put to death upon his own confession, since it is possible he may not be in his right mind F15; but David chose to exercise severity in this case, partly to show his respect to Saul, and to ingratiate himself into the favour of his friends, and partly to deter men from attempting to assassinate princes, who himself was now about to ascend the throne.


FOOTNOTES:

F14 Hilchot Sanhedrin, c. 18. sect. 6.
F15 T. Bab. Yehamot, fol. 25. 2. Maimon. ibid.

2 Samuel 1:16 In-Context

14 "Do you mean to say," said David, "that you weren't afraid to up and kill God's anointed king?"
15 Right then he ordered one of his soldiers, "Strike him dead!" The soldier struck him, and he died.
16 "You asked for it," David told him. "You sealed your death sentence when you said you killed God's anointed king."
17 Then David sang this lament over Saul and his son Jonathan,
18 and gave orders that everyone in Judah learn it by heart. Yes, it's even inscribed in The Book of Jashar.
Published by permission. Originally published by NavPress in English as THE MESSAGE: The Bible in Contemporary Language copyright 2002 by Eugene Peterson. All rights reserved.