Numeri 20:5

5 E perché ci avete fatti salire dall’Egitto per menarci in questo tristo luogo? Non è un luogo dove sì possa seminare; non ci son fichi, non vigne, non melagrane, e non c’è acqua da bere".

Numeri 20:5 Meaning and Commentary

Numbers 20:5

And wherefore have ye made us to come up out of Egypt
They represent that affair in such a light, as if they were forced out of Egypt by Moses and Aaron against their wills; or at least were overpersuaded by them to do what they had no inclination to, namely, to come out of Egypt; though they were in the utmost bondage and slavery, and their lives were made bitter by it, and they cried by reason of their oppression, and the hardships they endured; but this was all forgot. Aben Ezra says, it is a strange word which is here used, which shows the confusion they were in:

to bring us unto this evil place;
dry and barren, where there were neither food nor drink, as follows:

it is no place of seed;
or fit for sowing, as the Targum of Jonathan, any sort of seed, as wheat, barley, rye, rice

or of figs, or vines, or pomegranates;
it is not a soil fit to plant such trees in, nor would they grow were they planted:

neither is there any water to drink;
for them and their cattle, and therefore must be a miserable place for so large a body of people to subsist in.

Numeri 20:5 In-Context

3 E il popolo contese con Mosè, dicendo: "Fossimo pur morti quando morirono i nostri fratelli davanti all’Eterno!

4 E perché avete menato la raunanza dell’Eterno in questo deserto per morirvi noi e il nostro bestiame?

5 E perché ci avete fatti salire dall’Egitto per menarci in questo tristo luogo? Non è un luogo dove sì possa seminare; non ci son fichi, non vigne, non melagrane, e non c’è acqua da bere".

6 Allora Mosè ed Aaronne s’allontanarono dalla raunanza per recarsi all’ingresso della tenda di convegno; si prostrarono con la faccia in terra, e la gloria dell’Eterno apparve loro.

7 E l’Eterno parlò a Mosè, dicendo: