Richter 21:14

14 Und Benjamin kehrte in selbiger Zeit zurück; und sie gaben ihnen die Weiber, welche sie hatten leben lassen von den Weibern von Jabes-Gilead; aber sie fanden so nicht genug für sie.

Richter 21:14 Meaning and Commentary

Judges 21:14

And Benjamin came again at that time
The six hundred Benjaminites returned with the messengers at the same time to the people of Israel, putting confidence in the assurances they had given them of peace and safety:

and they gave them wives which they had saved alive of the women of
Jabeshgilead;
in doing which they supposed they had not violated their oath, since though they had sworn that they would not give their own daughters, they had not sworn they would not give the daughters of others; and besides, as the men of Jabeshgilead were not at Mizpeh when the oaths were made, they had taken none, and so their daughters might be given in marriage to the Benjaminites, notwithstanding that oath:

and yet so they sufficed them not;
there were not wives enough for them all; for they were six hundred men, whereas the daughters of the inhabitants of Jabeshgilead were but four hundred, so that there were two hundred more wanting. Abarbinel interprets the word we render "so" in a different manner, by "right", as in ( Numbers 27:7 ) and gives the sense thus, that it was not a point of justice and judgment to do this to the daughters of Jabeshgilead, namely, to save and give them in marriage; but they did this because the people repented for Benjamin, as follows.

Richter 21:14 In-Context

12 Und sie fanden unter den Bewohnern von Jabes-Gilead vierhundert Mädchen, Jungfrauen, die keinen Mann im Beischlaf erkannt hatten; und sie brachten sie ins Lager nach Silo, das im Lande Kanaan ist.

13 Und die ganze Gemeinde sandte hin und redete zu den Kindern Benjamin, die am Felsen Rimmon waren, und entbot ihnen Frieden.

14 Und Benjamin kehrte in selbiger Zeit zurück; und sie gaben ihnen die Weiber, welche sie hatten leben lassen von den Weibern von Jabes-Gilead; aber sie fanden so nicht genug für sie.

15 Und das Volk ließ sich's gereuen wegen Benjamins, weil Jehova einen Riß gemacht hatte in den Stämmen Israels.

16 Und die Ältesten der Gemeinde sprachen: Was sollen wir den Übriggebliebenen tun betreffs der Weiber? Denn die Weiber sind aus Benjamin vertilgt.