THE ELEVENTH BOOK.
AUGUSTINE BREAKS OFF THE HISTORY OF THE MODE WHEREBY GOD LED HIM TO HOLY ORDERS, IN ORDER TO " CONFESS" GOD'S MERCIES IN OPENING TO HIM THE SCRIPTURE — MOSES IS NOT TO BE UNDERSTOOD, BUT IN CHRIST, — NOT even the first words, " IN THE BEGINNING GOD CREATED THE HEAVEN AND THE EARTH"-- ANSWER TO CAVILLERS, WHO ASKED, WHAT DID GOD BEFORE HE CREATED THE HEAVEN AND THE EARTH, AND WHENCE WILLED HE AT LENGTH TO MAKE THEM, WHEREAS HE DID NOT MAKE THEM BEFORE—INQUIRY INTO THE NATURE OF TIME.
I. 1. Lord, since eternity is Thine, art Thou ignorant of what I say to Thee? or dost Thou see in time, what passeth in time? Why then do I lay in order before Thee so many relations? Not, of a truth, that Thou mightest learn them through me, but to stir up mine own, and my readers' devotions towards Thee, that we may all say, Great is the Lord, and greatly to be praised} I have said already, and again will say, for love of Thy love do I this. For we pray, also; and yet Truth hath said, your Father knoweth what you have need of, before you ash? It is then our affections which we lay open unto Thee, confessing our own miseries, and Thy mercies upon us, that Thou mayest free us Augustine prays to be kept from error. 801
1 Ps. xcvi. g. 2 Matt. vi. 8.
wholly, since Thou hast begun, that we may cease to be wretched in ourselves, and be blessed in Thee; seeing Thou hast called us, to become poor in spirit, and meek, and mourners, and hungering and athirst after righteousness, and merciful, and pure in heart, and peace-makers} See, I have told Thee many things, as I could and as I would, because Thou first wouldest that I should confess unto Thee, my Lord God. For Thou art good, for Thy mercy endureth forever?
II. 2. But how shall I suffice with the tongue of my pen to utter all Thy exhortations, and all Thy terrors, and comforts, and guidances, whereby Thou broughtest me to preach Thy Word, and dispense Thy Sacrament to Thy people? And if I suffice to utter them in order, the drops of time are precious with me; and long have I burned to meditate in Thy law? and therein to confess to Thee my skill and unskilfulness, the day-break of Thy enlightening and the remnants of my darkness, until infirmity be swallowed up by strength. And I would not have aught besides steal away those hours, which I find free from the necessities of refreshing my body and the powers of my mind, and the service which we owe to men, or which, though we owe not, we yet pay.
3. O Lord my God, give ear unto my prayer, and let Thy mercy hearken unto my desire: because it is anxious, not for myself alone, but would serve brotherly charity; and Thou seest my heart, that so it is. I would sacrifice to Thee the service of my 302 Augustine prays for light
1 Matt. T. 3—9. 2 Ps. exxxvi. 3 Ps. cxix. 97.
thought and tongue; do Thou give me what I may offer Thee. For I am poor and needy, Thou rich to all that call upon Thee;1 and, inaccessible to care, carest for us. Circumcise from all rashness and all lying both my inward and outward lips; let Thy Scriptures be my pure delights; let me not be deceived in them, nor deceive out of them. Lord, hearken and pity, O Lord my God, Light of the blind, and Strength of the weak; yea, also, Light of those that see, and Strength of the strong: hearken unto my soul, and hear it crying out of the depths? For if Thine ears be not with us in the depths also, whither shall we go? whither cry? The day is Thine, and the night is Thine; at Thy beck the moments flee by. Grant thereof a space for our meditations in the hidden things of Thy law, and close it not against us who knock. For not in vain wouldest Thou have the darksome secrets of so many pages written; nor are those forests without their harts, which retire therein and range and walk, feed, lie down, and ruminate. Perfect me, O Lord, and reveal them unto me. Behold, Thy voice is my joy; Thy voice exceedeth the abundance of pleasures. Give what I love: for I do love; and this hast Thou given. Forsake not Thy own gifts, nor despise Thy green herb that thirsteth. Let me confess unto Thee whatsoever I shall find in Thy books, and hear the voice of praise, and drink in Thee, and meditate on the wonderful things out of Thy law / even from the beginning, wherein Thou madest the and true knowledge. 303
1 Pb. xl. 17, lxxxvi. 5. * Ps. cxxx. 1.
heaven and the earth, unto the everlasting reigning of Thy holy city with Thee.
4. Lord, have mercy on me, and hear my desire. For it is not, I deem, desire of the earth, not of gold and silver and precious stones, or gorgeous apparel, or honors and offices, or the pleasures of the flesh, or necessaries for the body and for this life of our pilgrimage, — all which shall be added unto those that seek Thy kingdom and Thy righteousness. Behold, O Lord my God, wherein is my desire. The wicked have told me of delights, but not such as Thy law,
O Lord. Behold wherein is my desire. Behold, Father, behold, and see and approve; and be it pleasing in the sight of Thy mercy, that I may find grace before Thee, that the inward parts of Thy words be opened to me knocking. I beseech by our Lord Jesus Christ, Thy Son, the Man of Thy right hand, the Son of Man, whom Thou hast established for Thyself, as Thy Mediator and ours, through Whom Thou songhtest us who did not seek Thee, but soughtest us, that we might seek Thee; Thy
Word, through Whom Thou madest all things, and among them, me also; Thy Only Begotten, through whom Thou calledst to adoption the believing people, and therein me also, — I beseech Thee by Him, who sitteth at Thy right hand, and intercedeth with Thee for us, in Whom are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge. Him do I seek in Thy books. Of Him did Moses write. This saith He Himself; this saith the Truth.1
1 John v. 46.
304 The meaning of Moses.
III. 5. I would hear and understand how, " In the Beginning Thou madest the heaven and earth." Moses wrote this, wrote and departed, passed hence from Thee to Thee. Nor is he now before me; for if he were, I would hold him, and ask him, and beseech him by Thee to open these things unto me, and would lay the ears of my body to the sounds bursting out of his mouth. And should he speak Hebrew, in vain will it strike on my senses, nor would aught of it touch my mind; but if Latin, I should know what he said. But whence should I know whether he spake the truth? Yea, and if I knew this also, should I know it from him? Truly within me, within, in the chamber of my thoughts, Truth, Who is neither Hebrew, nor Greek, nor Latin, nor barbarian, without organs of voice or tongue, or sound of syllables, would say, "It is truth;" and I forthwith should say confidently to that man of Thine, "Thou sayest truly." Whereas, then, I cannot inquire of Moses, Thee, Thee I beseech, O Truth, being filled with Whom, he spake truth, Thee, my God, I beseech, forgive my sins; and Thou, who gavest him to speak these things, give to me also to understand them.
IV. 6. Behold, the heavens and the earth are; they proclaim that they were created; for they change and vary. Whereas whatsoever hath not been made, and yet is, hath nothing in it which it had not before; and this it is, to change and vary. They proclaim, also, that they made not themselves; "We are, because we have been made; we were not, God does not create from existing materials. 305
therefore, before we were, so as to make ourselves." Now the evidence of the thing is the voice of the speakers. Thou, therefore, Lord, madest them; who art beautiful, for they are beautiful; who art good, for they are good; who art, for they are; yet are they not beautiful, nor good, as Thou art, nor are they as Thou their Creator art; compared with Whom, they are neither beautiful, nor good, nor are. This we know, thanks be to Thee. And our knowledge, compared with Thy knowledge, is ignorance.
V. 7. But how didst Thou make the heaven and the earth? and what was the engine of Thy so mighty fabric? For it was not as a human artificer, forming one body from another, according to the discretion of his mind, which can in some way invest with such a form, as it seeth in itself by its inward eye. And whence should he be able to do this, unless Thou hadst made that mind? for he invests with a form what already exists and has a being, as clay, or stone, or wood, or gold, or the like. And whence should they be, hadst not Thou appointed them? Thou madest the artificer's body; his mind commanding his limbs; the matter whereof he makes anything; the apprehension whereby to take in his art, and see within, what he doth without; the sense of his body, whereby, as by an interpreter, he may from mind to matter convey that which he doth, and report to his mind what is done; that his mind may consult the truth, which presideth over it, whether it be well done or no. All these praise Thee, the Creator of all. But how dost Thou make 806 God does not create from existing materials.
them? how, O God, didst Thou make heaven and earth? Verily, neither in the heaven, nor in the earth, didst Thou make heaven and earth: nor in the air, or waters, seeing these also belong to the heaven and the earth; nor in the whole world didst Thou make the whole world; because there was no place where to make it, before it was made, that it might be. Nor didst Thou hold anything in Thy hand, whereof to make heaven and earth. For whence shouldest Thou have this, which Thou hadst not made, thereof to make anything? For what is, but because Thou art? Therefore Thou spakest, and they were made, and in Thy Word Thou madest them.
VI. 8. But how didst Thou speak? In the way that the voice came out of the cloud, saying, This is my beloved Son f1 For that voice passed by and passed away, began and ended; the syllables sounded and passed away, the second after the first, the third after the second, and so forth in order, until the last after the rest, and silence after the last. Whence it is abundantly clear and plain that the motion of a creature expressed it, itself temporal, serving Thy eternal will. And these Thy words, created for a time, the outward ear reported to the intelligent soul, whose inward ear lay listening to Thy Eternal Word. But she compared these words sounding in time, with Thy Eternal Word in silence, and said, "It is different, far different. These words are far beneath me, nor are they, because they flee The creative word not vocal. 307
1 Matt. iii. 17, xvii. 5.
and pass away; but the Word of my Lord abideth above me forever." If, then, in sounding and passing words thou saidst that heaven and earth should be made, and so madest heaven and earth, there was a corporeal creature before heaven and earth, by whose motions in time that voice might take his course in time. But there was nought corporeal before heaven and earth; or if there were, surely Thou hadst, without such a passing voice, created that whereof to make this passing voice, by which to say, Let the heaven and the earth be made. For whatsoever that were, whereof such a voice were made, unless by Thee it were made, it could not be at all. By what Word then didst Thou speak, that a substance might be made, whereby these words again might be made?
VII. 9. Thou callest us then to understand the Word, God with Thee God, Which is spoken eternally, and by It are all things spoken eternally. For what was spoken was not spoken successively, one thing concluded that the next might be spoken, but all things together and eternally. Else have we time and change; and not a true eternity nor true immortality. This I know, O my God, and give thanks. I know, I confess to Thee, O Lord, and with me doth know and bless Thee, whoso is not unthankful to assured Truth. We know, Lord, we know; since, inasmuch as anything is not, which was, and is, which was not, so far forth it dieth and ariseth. Nothing then of Thy Word doth give place or succeed, because It is truly immortal and eternal. 308 The eternal Word
And therefore unto the Word coeternal with Thee Thou dost at once and eternally say all that Thou dost say; and whatever Thou gayest shall be made, is made; nor dost Thou make, otherwise than by saying; and yet are not all things made together, or everlasting, which Thou makest by saying.
VIII. 10. Why, I beseech Thee, O Lord my God? I see it in a way; but how to express it, I know not, unless it be, that whatsoever begins to be, and leaves off to be, begins then, and leaves off then, when in Thy eternal Reason it is known, that it ought to begin or leave off; in which Reason Itself, nothing beginneth or leaveth off. This is Thy Word, which is also "the Beginning, because also It speaketh unto us."1 Thus, in the Gospel, He speaketh through the flesh; and this sounded outwardly in the ears of men, that it might be believed, and sought inwardly, and found in the eternal Verity; where the good and only Master teacheth all His disciples. There, Lord, hear I Thy voice speaking unto me; because He speaketh unto us, Who teacheth us. But he that teacheth us not, though He speaketh, to us He speaketh not. Who now teacheth us, but the unchangeable Truth? for even when we are admonished through a changeable creature, we are but led to the unchangeable Truth; where we learn truly, while we stand and hear Him, and rejoice greatly because of the Bridegroom's voice, restoring us to Him, from Whom we are. And He is therefore the Beginning, because unless He abide, is the Creator. 309
1 John viii. 25.
there should not be whither to return, when we went astray. But when we return from error, it is through knowing that we return; and that we may know, He teacheth us, because He is the Beginning, and speaketh unto us.
IX. 11. In this Beginning, O God, hast Thou made heaven and earth, in Thy Word, in Thy Son, in Thy Power, in Thy Wisdom, in Thy Truth; wondrously speaking, and wondrously making. Who shall comprehend? Who declare it? What is that which gleams through me, and strikes my heart without hurting it, and I shudder and kindle? I shudder, inasmuch as I am unlike it; I kindle, inasmuch as I am like it. It is Wisdom, Wisdom's self which gleameth through me; disparting my cloudiness which yet again mantles over me, shrinking from it, through the darkness which for my punishment gathers upon me. For my strength is brought down in need, so that I cannot support my blessings, till Thou, Lord, Who hast been gracious to all mine iniquities, shalt heal all my infirmities. For Thou shalt also redeem my life from corruption, and crown me with loving-kindness and tender mercies, and shalt satisfy my desire with good things, because my youth shall be renewed like an eagle's} For in hope we are saved, wherefore we through patience wait for Thy promises. Let him that is able, hear Thee inwardly discoursing, I will boldly cry out of Thy oracle, How wonderful are Thy Works, 0 Lord, in Wisdom hast Thou made them all? 310 The difference between
1 Ps. ciii. 3 eq. 2 Pa ck.. 24.,pagebreak/>
And this Wisdom is the Beginning, and in that Beginning didst Thou make heaven and earth.
X. 12. Lo, are they not full of their old leaven, who say to us, "What was God doing before He made heaven and earth f" "For if (say they) He were unemployed and wrought not, why does He not also henceforth, and forever, as He did heretofore? For did any new motion arise in God, and a new will to make a creature, which he had never before made, how then would that be a true eternity, where there ariseth a will, which was not? For the will of God is not a creature, but before the creature; seeing nothing could be created, unless the will of the Creator had preceded. The will of God, then, belongeth to His very Substance. And if aught have arisen in God's Substance, which before was not, that Substance cannot be truly called eternal. But if the will of God has been from eternity that the creature should be, why was not the creature from eternity?"
XL 13. They who speak thus, do not yet understand Thee, O Wisdom of God, Light of souls; understand not yet how the things be made, which by Thee, and in Thee are made: yet they strive to comprehend things eternal, whilst their heart fluttereth between the motions of things past and to come, and is still unstable. Who shall hold their heart, and fix it, that it be settled awhile, and awhile catch the glory of that ever-fixed Eternity, and compare it with the times which are never fixed, and see that it cannot be compared; and that a long time time and eternity. 311 812 Time is created.
cannot become long but out of many motions passing by, which motions cannot be prolonged altogether; but that in the Eternal nothing passeth, but the whole is present; whereas no time is all at once present: and that all time past is driven on by time to come, and all to come followeth upon the past; and all past and to come, is created, and flows out of that which is ever present? Who shall hold the heart of man, that it may stand still, and see how eternity ever still-standing, neither past nor to come, uttereth the times past and to come? Can my hand do this, or the hand of my mouth by speech bring about a thing so great?
XII. 14. See, I answer him that asketh, "What did God before He made heaven and earth?" I answer not as one is said to have done, merrily (clading the pressure of the question), "He was preparing l hell for pryers into mysteries." It is one thing to answer inquiries, another to make sport of inquirers. I answer not thus; for rather had I answer, "I know not," what I know not, than so answer as to raise a laugh at him who asketh deep things, and gain praise as one who answereth false things. But I say that Thou, our God, art the Creator of every crea- '. ture; and if by the name "heaven and earth," every creature be understood, I boldly say, that before God made heaven and earth, He did not make anything. For if He made, what did He make but a creature? And would that I knew whatsoever I desire to know to my profit, as surely as I know that
no creature was made, before there was made any creature.
XIII. 15. But if any excursive brain rove over the images of forepassed times, and wonder that Thou the God Almighty and All-creating and Allsupporting, Maker of heaven and earth, didst for innumerable ages forbear from so great a work, before Thou wouldest make it; let him awake and consider, that he wonders at false conceits. For whence could innumerable ages pass by, which Thou madest not, Thou the Author and Creator of all ages? or what times should there be, which* were not made by Thee? or how should they pass by, if they never were? Seeing, then, Thou art the Creator of all times, if any time was before Thou madest heaven and earth, why say they that Thou didst forego working? For that very time didst Thou make, nor could times pass by, before Thou madest those times. But if before heaven and earth there was no time, why is it demanded, what Thou then didst? For there was no "then," when there was no time.
16. Nor dost Thou by time precede time: else shouldest thou not precede all times. But Thou precedest all things past, by the sublimity of an ever-present eternity; and surpassest all future because they are future, and when they come, they shall be past; but Thou art the Same, and Thy years fail not. Thy years neither come nor go; whereas ours both come and go, that they all may come. Thy years stand together, because they do stand; nor are, departing, thrust out by coming years, 315
The idea of time inexplicable.
for they pass not away; but ours shall all be, wRy' they shall be no more. Thy years are one day; and Thy day is not daily, but to-day, seeing Thy to-day gives not place unto to-morrow, for neither doth it replace yesterday. Thy to-day is Eternity, therefore didst Thou beget The Coeternal, to whom Thou saidst, This day have I begotten Thee? Thou hast made all things; and before all times Thou art; y *'-.'neither in any time was time not.
XIV. 17. At no time, then, hadst Thou not made anything, because time itself Thou madest. And no times are coeternal with Thee because Thou abidest; but if they abode, they should not be times. For what is time? Who can readily and briefly explain this? Who can even in thought comprehend it, so as to utter a word about it? But what in discourse do we mention more familiarly and knowingly, than time? And we understand, when we speak of it; we understand, also, when we hear it spoken of by another. What then is time? If no one asks me, I know; if I wish to explain it to one that asketh, I know not; yet I say boldly, that I know that if nothing passed away, time past were not; and if nothing were coming, a time to come were not; and if nothing were, time present were not. Those two times then, past and to come, how are they, seeing the past now is not, and that to come is not yet? But the present, should it always be present, and never pass into time past, verily it should not be time, but eternity. If, therefore, time
1 Ps. ii. 7; Heb. v. 5.
314 time present ia
present, in order to be time at all, comes into existence only because it passes into time past, how can we say that that is in existence, whose cause of being is that it shall not be? How is it that we cannot truly say that time is, but because it is tending not to be?
XV. 18. And yet we say, "a long time " and a "short time;" still, only of time past or to come. A long time past (for example) we call an hundred years since; and a long time to come, an hundred years hence. But a short time past, we call (suppose) ten days since; and a short time to come, ten days hence. But in what sense is that long or short, which is not? For the past, is not now; and the future, is not yet. Let us not, then, say, " It is long;" but of the past, "It hath been long;" and of the future, "It will be long." O my Lord, my Light, shall not here also Thy Truth mock at man? For that past time which was long, was it long when it was now past, or when it was yet present? For then might it be long, when there was what could be long; but when past, it was no longer; wherefore, neither could that be long, which was not at all. Let us not, then, say, "Time past hath been long;" for we shall not find what hath been long, seeing that since it was past, it is no more; but let us say, "that present time was long;" because, when it was present, it was long. For it had not yet passed away, so as not to be; and therefore there was, what could be long; but after it was past, that ceased also to be long, which ceased to be.
an indivisible moment.
19. Let us see, then, thou soul of man, whether present time can be long; for to thee it is given to feel and to measure length of time. What wilt thou answer me? Are an hundred years, when present, a long time? See first whether an hundred years can be present. For if the first of these years be now current, it is present, but the other ninety and nine are to come, and therefore are not yet; bat if the second year be current, one is now past, another present, the rest to come. And so if we assume any middle year of this hundred to be present, all before it are passed; all after it to come; wherefore an hundred years cannot be present. But see at least whether that one which is now current, itself is present; for if the current month be its first, the rest are to come; if the second, the first is already past, and the rest are not yet. Therefore neither is the year now current present; and it' not present as a whole, then is not the year present. For twelve months are a year; of which, whatever be the current month is present; the rest past or to come. Although neither is that current month present, but one day, only; the rest being to come, if it be the first; past, if the last; if any of the middle, then amid past and to come.
20. See how the present time, which alone we found could be called long, is abridged to the length scarce of one day. But let us examine that also; because, neither is one day present as a whole. For it is made up of four and twenty hours of night and day; of which, the first hath the rest to come; the last hath them past; and any of the middle hath 316 Contradictions involved in
those before it past, those behind it to come. Yea, that one hour passeth away in flying particles. Whatsoever of it hath flown away, is past; whatsoever remained), is to come. If an instant of time be conceived, which cannot be divided into the smallest particles of moments, that alone is it, which may be called present. Which yet flies with such speed from future to past, as not to be lengthened out with the least stay. For if it be, it is divided into past and future. The present hath no space. Where then is the time which we may call long? Is it to come? But, of this we do not say, "It is long," because it is not yet at all, so as to be long; but we say, "It will be long." When, therefore, will it be long? For if, while it is yet in the future, it cannot be long (because what does not exist cannot be long), and, therefore, can be long only when from the future, which as yet is not, it shall begin now to be, and have become present, that so there should exist what maybe long,— if this be so, then does time present cry out, in the words above, that it cannot be long.
XVI. 21. And yet, Lord, we perceive intervals of times, and compare them, and say, some are shorter, and others longer. We measure, also, how much longer or shorter this time is than that; and we answer, "This is double, or treble, and that, but once, or only just so much as that." But we measure times as they are passing, by perceiving them; but past, which now are not, or the future, which are not yet, who can measure? unless a man shall presume to say, that can be measured which is not. When the time the idea of time. 317
is passing, it may be perceived and measured; but when it is past, it cannot, because it is not.
XVII. 22. I ask, Father, I affirm not; O my God, rule and guide me. Who will tell me that there are not three times (as we learned when boys, and taught boys), past, present, and future, but only one, the present, because those two are not? Or are they also; and when from future it becometh present, doth it come out of some secret place; and so, when retiring, from present it becometh past? For where did they, who foretold things to come, see them, if as yet they be not? For that which is not, cannot be seen. And they who relate things past, could not relate them, if in mind they did not discern them, and if they were not, they could no way be discerned. Things then past and to come are. ,
XVIII. M. Permit me, Lord, to seek further. O my Hope, let not my purpose be confounded. For if times past and to come be, I would know where they be. Which yet if I cannot, yet I know, whereever they be, they are not there as future, or past, but present. For if there also they be future, they are not yet there; if there also they be past, they are no longer there. Wheresoever then is whatsoever is, it is only as present. Although when past facts are related, there are drawn out of the memory, not the things themselves which are past, but words, which, conceived by the images of the things, they, in passing, have through the senses left as traces in the mind. Thus my childhood, which now is not, is in time past, which now is not; but now when I re318 Past and future conceived as present.
call its image, and tell of it, I behold it in the present, because it is still in my memory. Whether there be a like cause of foretelling things to come also, so that of things which as yet are not, the images may be perceived before already existing, I confess, O my God, I know not. This indeed I know, that we generally think before on our future actions, and that that forethinking is present, but the action whereof we forethink is not yet, because it is to come. Which, when we have set upon, and have begun to do what we were forethinking, then shall that action be; because then it is no longer future, but present.
24. Which way soever, then, this secret receiving of things to come be, that only can bejseen. '^ which is. But what now is, is not future, but present. When, then, things to come are said to be seen, it is not themselves, which as yet are not (that is, which are to be), but their causes, perchance, or signs, are seen, which already are. Therefore they are not future but present to those who now see that from which the future, being fore-conceived in the mind, is foretold. Which fore-conceptions again now are; and those who foretell those things, do behold'the conceptions present before them. Let now the numerous variety of things furnish me some example. I behold the daybreak, I foretell that the sun is about to rise. What I behold, is present; what I fore-signify, to come; not the sun, which already is; but the sun-rising, which is not yet. And yet did I not in my mind imagine the sun-rising itself (as now while I speak of it), I could not foretell it. But neither is
God's foreknowledge inexplicable. 319
that day-break, which I discern in the sky, the sunrising, although it goes before it; nor that imagination of my mind; which two are seen now present, that the other which is to be may be foretold. Future things then are not yet; and if they be not yet, they are not; and if they are not, they cannot be seen; yet foretold they may be from things present, which are already, and are seen.
XIX. 25. Thou, then, Ruler of Thy creation, by what way dost Thou teach souls things to come? For Thou didst teach Thy Prophets. By what way dost Thou, to Whom nothing is to come, teach things to come; or, rather, concerning the future, dost teach things present? For, what is not, cannot be taught. Too far is this way out of my ken: it is too mighty for me, I cannot attain unto it• but from Thee I can, when Thou shalt vouchsafe it, O sweet Light of my hidden eyes.
XX. 26. What now is clear and plain is, that neither things to come nor past are. Nor is it properly said, "There be three times, past, present, and to come:" yet perchance it might be properly said, "There be three times; a present of things past, a present of things present, and a present of things future." For these three do exist, in some sort, in the soul, but otherwise do I not see them: a present of things past, memory; a present of things present, sight; a present of things future, expectation. If thus we be permitted to speak, I see three times, and I confess there are three. Let it be said, too, "There be three times, past, present, and to come," in our in320 how time is measured.
correct way. See, I object not, nor gainsay, nor find fault, if what is so said be but understood, that neither what is to be, now is, nor what is past. For there are but few things which we speak properly, most things improperly; still the things intended are understood.
XXI. 27. I said then even now, we measure times as they pass, in order to be able to say, this time is twice so much as that one; or, this is just so much as that; and so of any other part of time which is measurable. Wherefore, as I said, we measure times as they pass. And if any should ask me, "How knowest Thou?" I might answer, "I know that we do measure, nor can we measure things that are not; and things past and to come are not." But time present how do we measure, seeing it hath no space? It is measured while passing, but when it shall have passed, it is not measured; for there will be nothing to be measured. But whence, by what way, and whither passes it, while it is a measuring? whence, but from the future? which way but through the present? whither, but into the past? From that, therefore, which is not yet, through that, which hath no space, into that, which now is not. Yet what do we measure, if not time in some space? For we do not say single, and double, and triple, and equal, or any other like way that we speak of time, except of spaces of times. In what space, then, do we measure time passing? In the future, into which it passes? But what is not yet, we measure not. Or in the present, through which it passes? But no space, Augustine prays for light. 321
we do not measure. Or in the past, to which it passes? But neither do we measure that which now is not.
XXII. 28. My soul is on fire to know this most intricate enigma. Shut it not up, O Lord my God, good Father; through Christ I beseech Thee, do not shut up these usual, yet hidden things from my desire, that it be hindered from piercing into them; but let them dawn through Thy enlightening mercy, O Lord. Whom shall I inquire of concerning these things? and to whom shall I more fruitfully confess my ignorance, than to Thee, to Whom these my studies, so vehemently kindled towards Thy Scriptures, are not so troublesome? Give what I love; for I do love, and this hast Thou given me. Give, Father, Who truly knowest to give good gifts unto Thy children. Give, because I have taken upon me to know, and trouble is before me until Thou openest it. By Christ, I beseech Thee, in His Name, Holy of Holies, let no man disturb me. For I believed, and therefore do I speak. This is my hope, for this do I live, that I may contemplate the delights of the Lord. Behold, Thou hast made my days old, and they pass away, and how, I know not. And we talk of time and time, and times and times. "How long time is it since he said this?" "how long time since he did this?" and, "how long time since I saw that?" and, "this syllable hath double time to that single short syllable." These words we speak, and these we hear, and are understood, and understand. Most manifest and ordinary they are, and the self-same things again 322 Time is not motion.
are but too deeply hidden, and the discovery of them were new.
XXIII. 26. I heard once from a learned man, that the motions of the sun, moon and stars constituted time, and I assented not. For why should not, rather, the motions of all bodies be times? Or, if the lights of heaven should cease, and a potter's wheel run round, would there be no time by which we might measure those whirlings, and say, that either it moved with equal pauses, or if it turned sometimes slower, otherwise quicker, that some rounds were longer, others shorter? Or, while we were saying this, should we not also be speaking in time? And would there not be in our words, some syllables short, others long, because those sounded in a shorter time, these in a longer? God grant to men to see in a small thing, notices common to things great and small. The stars and lights of heaven are also for signs, and for seasons, and for years and for days; they are; yet neither should I say that the going round of that wooden wheel was a day, nor yet he, that it was therefore no time.
30. I desire to know the force and nature of time, by which we measure the motions of bodies, and say, for example, "This motion is twice as long as that." For I ask, seeing "day" denotes not the stay only of the sun upon the earth (according to which, day is one thing, night another), but also its whole circuit from east to east again (according to which, we say, "there passed so many days," the night being included when we say, " so many days," and the nights not Time is an extension, or duration. 323
reckoned apart), — seeing then a day is completed by the motion of the sun, and by his circuit from east to east again, I ask, does the motion alone make the day, or the stay in which that motion is completed, or both? For, if the first be the day, then should we have a day, although the sun should finish that course in so small a space of time as one hour comes to. If the second, then should not that make a day, if between one sun-rise and another there were but so short a stay as one hour comes to; but the sun must go four and twenty times about to complete one day. If both, then neither could that be called a day, if the sun should run his whole round in the space of one hour; nor that, if, while the sun stood still, so much time should overpass, as the sun usually makes his whole course in, from morning to morning. I will not, therefore, now ask what that is which is called day; but, what time is, whereby we, measuring the circuit of the sun, should say that it was finished in half the time it was wont, if so be it was finished in so small a space as twelve hours; and comparing both times, should call this a single time, that a double time; even supposing the sun to run his round from east to east, sometimes in that single, sometimes in that double time. Let no man, then, tell me that the motions of the heavenly bodies constitute times because, when at the prayer of one the sun had stood still till he could achieve his victorious battle, the sun stood still, but time went on. For in its own allotted space of time was that 324 Time is not motion.
battle waged and ended.1 I perceive time, then, to be a certain extension. But do I perceive it, or seem to perceive it? Thou, Light and Truth, wilt show me. XXIV. 31. Dost Thou bid me assent, if any define time to be "motion of a body?" Thou dost not bid me. For that no body is moved, but in time, I hear; this Thou sayest; but that the motion of a body is time, I hear not; Thou sayest it not. For when a body is moved, I by time measure how long it moves, from the time it began to move, until it left off. And if I did not see whence it began, and it continue to move so that I see not when it ends, I cannot measure, save perchance from the time I began to see, until I cease to see. And if I look long, I can only pronounce it to be a long time, but not how long; because when we say "how long," we do it by comparison; as, "this is as long as that," or "this twice so long as that," or the like. But when we can mark the distances of the places, whence and whither goeth the body moved, or its parts, if it moved as in a lathe, then can we say precisely in how much time the motion of that body or its part, from this place unto that, was finished. Seeing, therefore, the motion of a body is one thing, that by which we measure how long it is, another; who sees not, which of the two is rather to be called time? And if a body sometimes moves, and sometimes stands still, then we measure not its motion only, but its standing still, too, by time; and we say, " it stood still as much as it moved;" or, "it stood still twice Augustine prays for illumination. 325
1 Joshua x. 12 sq.
or thrice as long as it moved;" or any other space which oar measuring hath either ascertained, or guessed; more or less, as we used to say. Time, then, is not the motion of a body.
XXV. 32. And I confess to Thee O Lord, that I yet know not what time is; and again I confess unto Thee, O Lord, that I know that I speak this in time, and that having long spoken of time, that very "long" is not long, but by the pause of time. How then know I this, seeing I know not what time is? or is it perchance that I know not how to express what I know? Woe is me, that do not even know what I do not know. Behold, O my God, before Thee I lie not; but as I speak, so is my heart. Thou shalt light my candle; Thou, O Lord my God, wilt enlighten my darkness.
XXVI. 33. Does not my soul most truly confess unto Thee that I do measure times? Do I then measure, O my God, and know not what I measure? I measure the motion of a body in time; and the time itself do I not measure? Or could I indeed measure the motion of a body, how long it were, and in how long space it could come from this place to that, without measuring the time in which it is moved? This same time, then, how do I measure? do we by a shorter time measure a longer, as by the space of a cubit, the space of a rood? for so indeed we seem by the space of a short syllable, to measure the space of a long syllable, and to say that this is double the other. Thus measure we the spaces of stanzas by the spaces of the verses, and the spaces of the verse
by the spaces of the feet, and the spaces of the feet by the spaces of the syllables, and the spaces of long by the spaces of short syllables, not measuring by pages (for then we measure spaces, not times); but when we utter the words and they pass by, we say, "It is a long stanza, because composed of so many verses; long verses, because consisting of so many feet; long feet, because prolonged by so many syllables; a long syllable, because double to a short one." But neither do we this way obtain any certain measure of time; because it may be that a shorter verse, pronounced more fully, may take up more time than a longer, pronounced hurriedly. And so for a verse, a foot, a syllable. Whence it seemed to me, that time is nothing else than protraction; but of what, I know not. And I wonder whether it be not of the mind itself? For what, I beseech Thee, O my God, do I measure, when I say, either indefinitely, "this is a longer time than that," or definitely, "this is double that?" That I measure time, I know; and yet I measure not time to come, for it is not yet; nor present, because it is not protracted by any space ; nor past, because it now is not. What then do I measure? Times passing, not past? for so I said.
XXVII. 34. Courage, my mind, and press on mightily. God is our helper, He made us, and not we ourselves. Press on where truth begins to dawn. Suppose, now, the voice of a body begins to sound, and does sound, and sounds on, and list, it ceases; it is silence now, and that voice is past, and is no more a voice. Before it sounded, it was to come, and Difficulties and contradictions. 327
could not be measured, because as yet it was not, and now it cannot, because it is no longer. Then, therefore, while it sounded, it might; because there then was what might be measured. But yet even then it was not at a stay; for it was passing on, and passing away. Could it be measured the rather, for that? For, while passing, it was being extended into some space of time, so that it might be measured, since the present hath no space. If, therefore, then it might, then, lo, suppose another voice hath begun to sound, and still soundeth in one continued tenor, without any interruption; let us measure it while it sounds; seeing when it hath left sounding, it will then be past, and nothing left to be measured; let us measure it verily, and tell how much it is. But it sounds -still, nor can it be measured but from the instant it began in, unto the end it left off in. For the very space between is the thing we measure; namely, from some beginning, unto some end. Wherefore, a voice that is not yet ended, cannot be measured, so that it may be said how long, or short it is; nor can it be called equal to another, or double to a single, or the like. But when ended, it no longer is. How may it then be measured? And yet we measure times; but yet neither those which are not yet, nor those which no longer are, nor those which are not lengthened out by some pause, nor those which have no bounds. We measure neither times to come, nor past, nor present, nor passing; and yet we do measure times.
35. "Deus Creator omnium," this verse of eight syllables alternates between short and long syllables. 328 Time is measured
The four short, then (the first, third, fifth, and seventh), are but single, in respect of the four long (the second, fourth, sixth, and eighth). Every one of the latter hath a double time to every one of the former; I pronounce them, report on them, and find it so, as one's plain sense perceives. By plain sense, then, I measure a long syllable by a short, and I sensibly find it to have twice so much; but when one sounds after the other, if the former be short, the latter long, how shall I detain the short one, and how, measuring, shall I apply it to the long, that I may find this to have twice so much; seeing the long does not begin to sound unless the short leaves sounding? And that long one itself, I do not measure while present, seeing I measure it not till it be ended? Now its ending is its passing away. What then is it I measure? where is the short syllable by which I measure? where the long which I measure? Both have sounded, have flown, passed away, are no more; and yet I measure, and confidently answer (so far as is presumed on a practised sense), that as to space of time this syllable is but single, that double. And yet I could not do this, unless they were already past and ended. It is not, then, themselves, which now are not, that I measure, but something in my memory, which there remains fixed.
36. It is in thee, my mind, that I measure times. Interrupt me not, that is, interrupt not thyself with the tumults of thy impressions. In thee I measure times; the impression, which things as they pass by cause in thee, remains even when they are gone; only when past. 329
this it is which still present, I measure, and not the things which pass by to make this impression. This I measure, when I measure times. Either, then, this is time, or I do not measure times. How is it then, when we measure silence, and say that this silence hath held as long time as did that voice? do we not stretch out our thought to the measure of a voice, as if it sounded; that so we may be able to report of the intervals of silence in a given space of time? For though both voice and tongue be still, yet in thought we go over poems, and verses, and any other discourse, or dimensions of motions, and report as to the spaces of times, how much this is in respect of that, no otherwise than if vocally we did pronounce them. If a man would utter a lengthened sound, and had settled in thought how long it should be, he hath in silence already gone through a space of time, and, committing it to memory, begins to utter that speech, which sounds on, until it be brought unto the end proposed. Yea it hath sounded, and will sound; for so much of it as is finished, hath sounded already, and the rest will sound. And thus passeth it on, until the present intent conveys over the future into the past; the past increasing by the diminution of the future, until by the consumption of the future, all is past.
XXVIII. 37. But how is that future diminished or consumed, which as yet is not? or how that past increased, which is now no longer, unless because that in the mind which enacts this, there be three things done? For it expects, it considers (attendit), it re330 Time is measured in the mind.
members; in such way that that which it expects, through that which it considers, passes into that which it remembers. Who therefore denies that things to come are not as yet? and yet, there is in the mind an expectation of things to come. And who denies past things to be now no longer? and yet there is still in the mind a memory of things past. And who denies that the present time hath no space, because it passes away in a moment? and yet our consideration (attentio) continues, through which that which shall be present proceeds to become absent. It is not then future time, that is long, for as yet it is not; but a "long future," is "a long expectation of the future." Nor is it time past, which now is not, that is long; but a "long past," is "a long memory of the past."
38. I am about to repeat a Psalm that I know. Before I begin, my expectation is extended over the whole; but when I have begun, how much soever of it I shall separate off into the past, is extended along my memory; thus the life of this action of mine is divided between my memory as to what I have repeated, and expectation as to what I am about to repeat; but "consideration" (attentio) is present with me, that through it, what was future may be conveyed over, so as to become past. Which the more it is done again and again, so much the more the expectation being shortened, is the memory enlarged; till the whole expectation be at length exhausted, when that whole action being ended, shall have passed into memory. And this which takes place in All distractions harmonized in God. 331
the whole Psalm, takes place in each several portion of it, and each several syllable; the same holds in that longer action, whereof this Psalm may be a part; the same holds in the whole life of man, whereof all the actions of man are parts; the same holds through the whole age of the sons of men, whereof all the lives of men are parts.
XXIX. 39. But because Thy loving kindness is better than all lives, behold, my life is but a distraction, and Thy right hand upheld me, in my Lord the Son of man, the Mediator betwixt Thee, The One, and us many (many also through our manifold distractions amid many things), that by Him I may apprehend in Whom I have been apprehended, and may be re-collected from my old conversation, to follow The One, forgetting what is behind, and, not distended, but extended, not to things which shall be and shall pass away, but to those things which are before, not distractedly but intently follow on for the prize of my heavenly calling where I may hear the voice of Thy praise, and contemplate Thy delights, ever coming, never passing away. But now are my years spent in mourning. And Thou, O Lord, art my comfort, my Father everlasting. But I have been severed amid times, whose order I know not; and my thoughts, even the inmost bowels of my soul, are rent and mangled with tumultuous varieties, until I flow together into Thee, purified and molten by the fire of Thy love.
XXX. 40. And now will I stand, and become solid in Thee, in my mould, Thy truth; nor will I endure 332 Time is created.
the questions of men, who by a penal disease thirst for more than they can contain, and say, "What did God before He made heaven and earth?" "Or, how came it into His mind to make anything, having never made anything?" Give them, O Lord, to bethink themselves what they say, and to find that "never" cannot be predicated, when "time" is not. This, then, that He is said "never to have made;" what else is it than to say, "in 'no time' to have made?" Let them see, therefore, that time cannot \* be without created being, and cease to speak that '* vanity. May they also be extended towards those things which are before' and understand Thee before all times the eternal Creator of all times, and that no times be coeternal with Thee, nor any creature, even if there be any creature before all times.
XXXI. 41. O Lord my God, what a depth is that recess of Thy mysteries, and how far from it have the consequences of my transgressions cast me! Heal mine eyes that I may share the joy of Thy light. Certainly, if there be a mind gifted with such vast knowledge and foreknowledge as to know all things past and to come, as I know one well-known Psalm, truly that mind is passing wonderful, and fearfully amazing; in that, nothing past, nothing to come in after ages, is any more hidden from him, than when I sung that Psalm, was hidden from me, what, and how much of it had passed away from the beginning, what, and how much there remained unto the end. But far be it, that Thou, the Creator of the universe, the Creator of souls and bodies, far be it, that thou God? s cognition different from man's. 333
shouldest in such wise know all past and to come. Far, far more wonderfully, and far more mysteriously, dost Thou know them. For not as the feelings of one who sings what he knows, or hears some well-known song, through expectation of the words to come, and the remembering of those that are past, are varied, and his senses divided, — not so doth any thing happen unto Thee, unchangeably eternal, that is, the Eternal Creator of minds. As, then, Thou in the Beginning knewest the heaven and the earth, without any variety of Thy knowledge, so madest Thou in the beginning, heaven and earth, without any distraction of thy action. Whoso understandeth, let him confess unto Thee; and whoso understandeth not, let him confess unto Thee. Oh, how high art Thou! and yet the humble in heart are Thy dwelling-place; for Thou raisest up those that are bowed down, and they fall not, whose elevation Thou art.