Hiob 11:2

2 Sollte die Menge der Worte nicht beantwortet werden, oder sollte ein Schwätzer recht behalten?

Hiob 11:2 Meaning and Commentary

Job 11:2

Should not the multitude of words be answered?
&c.] Zophar insinuates, that Job was a mere babbler, a talkative man, that had words, but no matter; said a great deal, but there was nothing in what he said; that his words were but wind, yea, in effect that he was a fool, who is commonly full of words, and is known by the multitude of them; and whereas he might think to bear down all before him in this way, and to discourage persons from giving him an answer; this Zophar suggests should not be the case, nor would he be deterred hereby from giving one, which he now undertook: some supply it, as Bar Tzemach, "should not a man of a multitude of words" F19 a verbose man, a dealer in many words, and nothing else, should not he be "answered?" if he uses nothing but words, and there is no argument in them, they seem not to deserve an answer, unless it be to show the emptiness of them, expose a man's folly, and pull down his pride and vanity:

and should a man full of talk be justified?
or "a man of lips" F20, an eloquent man, or one that affects to be so; a man of a fine speech, who artfully colours things, and makes a show of wisdom and truth, when there are neither in what he says; is such a man to be justified? he would seem to be in his own eyes at least, if not in the eyes of others, if not answered; he would be thought to have carried his point, to have had the better of the argument, and to have got the victory by dint of words and power of oratory; for this is not to be understood of justification before God; for as no man is heard and accepted by him for his "much speaking", as was the opinion of the Heathens, so neither are any justified on account of their many words, any more than their many works; since, in a multitude of words there are often not only much folly and weakness, but vanities and sins, ( Proverbs 10:19 ) ( Ecclesiastes 5:7 ) ; there is indeed a sense in which a man is justified by his words, ( Matthew 12:37 ) ; when he confesses Christ, and professes to be justified by his righteousness, and believes in that, and pleads it as his justifying righteousness; he is justified by that righteousness; which is contained in the confession and profession of his faith; but this is not here meant.


FOOTNOTES:

F19 (Myrbd brh) "an abundans verbis", Beza; "an multus verbis", Mercerus, so Kimchi & Ben Melech; and most Hebrew writers take (br) for an adjective.
F20 (Mytpv vya) "vir labiorum", Montanus, Beza, Drusius, Vatablus, Mercerus, Bolducius, Cocceius, Schmidt, Michaelis.

Hiob 11:2 In-Context

1 Und Zophar, der Naamathiter, antwortete und sprach:
2 Sollte die Menge der Worte nicht beantwortet werden, oder sollte ein Schwätzer recht behalten?
3 Sollte dein Gerede die Leute zum Schweigen bringen, daß du spotten solltest, und niemand dich beschämen,
4 daß du sagen solltest: Meine Lehre ist lauter, und ich bin rein in deinen Augen?
5 Aber möchte Gott doch reden und seine Lippen gegen dich öffnen,
The Elberfelder Bible is in the public domain.