But it is not as though (
ouc oion de oti). Supply
estin after
ouc: "But it is not such as that," an old idiom, here alone in N.T.
Hath come to nought (
ekpeptwken). Perfect active indicative of
ekpiptw, old verb, to fall out.
For they are not all Israel, which are of Israel (
ou gar pante oi ex Israhl outoi Israhl). "For not all those out of Israel (the literal Jewish nation), these are Israel (the spiritual Israel)." This startling paradox is not a new idea with Paul. He had already shown (
Galatians 3:7-9 ) that those of faith are the true sons of Abraham. He has amplified that idea also in
Romans 4:1 ff. So he is not making a clever dodge here to escape a difficulty. He now shows how this was the original purpose of God to include only those who believed.
Seed of Abraham (
sperma Abraam). Physical descent here, but spiritual seed by promise in verse
Romans 8 . He quotes
Genesis 21:12 .