Leviticus 27:10

10 He may not replace it or make a substitution for it, either good for bad, or bad for good.^[a] But if he does substitute one animal for another, both that animal and its substitute will be holy.

Leviticus 27:10 Meaning and Commentary

Leviticus 27:10

He shall not alter it nor change it
Some think these two words signify the same, but Abarbinel ^F19 makes them different; according to him, to "alter" is for one of another kind, as one of the herd for one of the flock, or the contrary; and to "change" for one of the same kind:

a good for a bad, or a bad for a good;
or, as the Targum of Jonathan,

``that which is perfect for that which has a blemish in it, or what has a blemish in it for that which is perfect;''

a change might not be made neither for the better nor for the worse, but the creature devoted was to be taken as it was; if not fit for sacrifice it was to be sold, and its price put to other uses; for, as Abarbinel ^F20 observes, whatsoever was devoted to sacred use was never to be put to any profane one; and this was also to teach men not to be hasty and fickle in such things, but to consider well what they did, and abide by it; for if such alterations and changes could be admitted of, a man after he had vowed might through covetousness repent, and bring a bad one instead of a good one, or, under pretence of bringing a good one instead of a bad one, might bring a bad one and say it was good, as Bechai ^F21 observes; even one worse than he had brought, thinking to impose upon the ignorance of the priest; and indeed if he was sincere in it, and had a mind to bring a better than what he had vowed, it was not allowed of; if he made any change, though it was for the better, he was to be beaten, as Maimonides ^F23 affirms:

and if he shall at all change beast for beast;
whether of the same or of a different kind, or whether for better or worse:

then it and the exchange thereof shall be holy:
both of them were to be the Lord's, and appropriated to sacred use, of one sort or another, either for sacrifice or for the priests family, or the price of it for the repairs of the sanctuary.

---

FOOTNOTES:

F19 Apud Muis. in loc.
F20 Ibid.
F21 Apud Muis. ib.
F23 Hilchot Temurah, c. 1. sect. 1.

Leviticus 27:10 In-Context

8 But if one is too poor to pay the valuation, he must present the person before the priest and the priest will set a value for him. The priest will set a value for him according to what the one making the vow can afford.

9 "If the vow involves one of the animals that may be brought as an offering to the Lord, any of these he gives to the Lord will be holy.

10 He may not replace it or make a substitution for it, either good for bad, or bad for good. But if he does substitute one animal for another, both that animal and its substitute will be holy.

11 "If the vow involves any of the unclean animals that may not be brought as an offering to the Lord, the animal must be presented before the priest.

12 The priest will set its value, whether high or low; the price will be set as the priest makes the valuation for you.

Footnotes

• [a]. Mal 1:8