
3 Hymns That Aren't Theologically Sound
August 26, 2026
Itâs a great comfort to know a beloved hymn we enjoy singing is theologically sound. Recently, I shared about five hymns (both old and modern) with lyrics pulled straight from Scripture, and itâs clear there are far more than just five. Some quote whole sections of the Bible verbatim, while other have just a line or two.
A hymn â the word comes from the Greek hymnos, meaning âsong of praiseâ â is a religious song or poem of worship to God. The earliest Christian hymn still preserved is from the third-century, and hymns are still written today (we might also call a modern hymn a âcontemporary Christian worship songâ).
But there are hymns that arenât theologically sound. And while the songs might be beautiful in their message, music, or the God-inspired imagery they evoke â even bringing us great comfort â they lift up ideas that arenât promised in the Bible.
Itâs not a bad thing to appreciate something thatâs not in the Bible. After all, the Bible doesnât mention every single thing in existence. Certainly, the internet is found nowhere in the Bible, yet millions of Christians worldwide deepen their faith every day because of the connectivity and wider access to knowledge it has introduced.
Yet sometimes, we sing our heart out to the Lord in worship, believing what we think is a truth about Jesus or the nature of God, but it turns out this so-called truth is nowhere in the Bible.
These hymns arenât necessarily bad or evil, but it is important to know they arenât accurate from a theological standpoint.
Letâs take a look at three hymns that arenât theologically sound:
Photo credit: Unsplash/Matthias Wagner
Jessica Brodie is an award-winning Christian novelist, journalist, editor, blogger, and writing coach. She is also the editor of the South Carolina United Methodist Advocate, the oldest newspaper in Methodism. Her Christian contemporary novel, 











