Giovanni 18:22

22 Ora quando Gesù ebbe dette queste cose, un de’ sergenti, ch’era quivi presente, gli diede una bacchettata, dicendo: Così rispondi tu al sommo sacerdote?

Giovanni 18:22 Meaning and Commentary

John 18:22

And when he had thus spoken
What was so right and reasonable, in so becoming a manner, without heat or passion:

one of the officers which stood by;
it may be one of those who had been sent to him and had been a hearer of him, whom Jesus might look wistfully at, or point unto, when he said the above words, at which he might be provoked: and therefore

stroke Jesus with the palm of his hand;
or gave him a rap with a rod, or smote him with a staff, as some think, is the sense of the phrase; though the Syriac, agreeably to our version, reads it, he smote him, (yhwewl le) , "upon his cheek"; gave him, what we commonly call, a slap on the face; and which is always esteemed a very great affront, and was a piece of rudeness and insolence to the last degree in this man:

saying, answerest thou the high priest so?
This he said, as well as gave the blow, either out of flattery to the high priest, or to clear himself from being a favourer of Christ; which, by what had been said, he might think would be suspected: some have thought this was Malchus, whose ear Christ had healed; if so, he was guilty of great ingratitude.

Giovanni 18:22 In-Context

20 Gesù gli rispose: Io ho apertamente parlato al mondo; io ho sempre insegnato nella sinagoga e nel tempio, ove i Giudei si raunano d’ogni luogo, e non ho detto niente in occulto.

21 Perchè mi domandi tu? domanda coloro che hanno udito ciò ch’io ho lor detto; ecco, essi sanno le cose ch’io ho dette.

22 Ora quando Gesù ebbe dette queste cose, un de’ sergenti, ch’era quivi presente, gli diede una bacchettata, dicendo: Così rispondi tu al sommo sacerdote?

23 Gesù gli rispose: Se io ho mal parlato, testimonia del male; ma, se ho parlato bene, perchè mi percuoti?

24 Anna adunque l’avea rimandato legato a Caiafa, sommo sacerdote.