Ésaïe 36:5

5 Je te le dis: ce ne sont là que des paroles! Le conseil et la force sont requis à la guerre; et maintenant, en qui t'es-tu confié, pour te révolter contre moi?

Ésaïe 36:5 Meaning and Commentary

Isaiah 36:5

I say, (sayest thou,) but they are but vain words
Or, "word of lips" F6; meaning the following, which he suggests were only the fruit of his lips, not of his heart; or were vain and foolish, and without effect, and stood for nothing; so the first part of the words are Hezekiah's, "I say (sayest thou)"; and the latter, Rabshakeh's note upon them; though they may be understood as Hezekiah's, or what he is made to speak by Rabshakeh, as the ground of his confidence, namely, "word of lips"; that is, prayer to God, as Kimchi explains it; or eloquence in addressing his soldiers, and encouraging them to fight, either of which Rabshakeh derides, as well as what follows: I have counsel and strength for war;
as he had; he had wise ministers to consult, and was capable of forming a good plan, and wise schemes, and of putting them in execution, and of heartening men; though he did not put his confidence in these things, as Rabshakeh suggested, ( 2 Chronicles 32:3-8 ) , the words may be rendered; "but counsel and strength are for war" F7: what signifies words to God, or eloquence with men? this is all lip labour, and of little service; wisdom and counsel to form plans, and power to execute them, are the things which are necessary to carry on a war with success, and which, it is intimated, were wanting in Hezekiah; and therefore he had nothing to ground his confidence upon, within himself, or his people: now on whom dost thou trust, that thou rebellest against me?
which it does not appear he had, having paid the money agreed to for the withdrawment of his army; but this was a pretence for the siege of Jerusalem.


FOOTNOTES:

F6 (Mytpv rbd) "verbum labiorum", Montanus; "vel, sermo labiorum", Vatablus.
F7 (hmxlml hrwbgw hue) "consilium et fortitudo ad praelium", Montanus; "sed consilio et fortitudine opus ad praelium", Pagninus, i.e. "requiruntur", ut Grotius.

Ésaïe 36:5 In-Context

3 Et Éliakim, fils de Hilkija, préfet du palais, se rendit vers lui, avec Shebna, le secrétaire, et Joach, fils d'Asaph, le chancelier.
4 Et Rabshaké leur dit: Dites, je vous prie, à Ézéchias: Ainsi dit le grand roi, le roi d'Assyrie: Qu'est-ce que cette confiance sur laquelle tu t'appuies?
5 Je te le dis: ce ne sont là que des paroles! Le conseil et la force sont requis à la guerre; et maintenant, en qui t'es-tu confié, pour te révolter contre moi?
6 Voici, tu te confies en l'Égypte, en ce bâton, ce roseau cassé, qui perce et traverse la main de celui qui s'y appuie: tel est Pharaon, roi d'Égypte, pour tous ceux qui se confient en lui.
7 Que si tu me dis: "Nous nous confions en l'Éternel, notre Dieu", n'est-ce pas lui dont Ézéchias a ôté les hauts lieux et les autels, disant à Juda et à Jérusalem: C'est devant cet autel-ci que vous vous prosternerez!
The Ostervald translation is in the public domain.