And refused to obey
 Though exhorted, admonished, and threatened, such was their obstinacy: 
 neither were mindful of thy wonders that thou didst among them;
 in delivering them at the Red sea, in raining manna about them, and giving them water out of the rock: 
 but hardened their necks;
 see the preceding verse: 
 and in their rebellion appointed a captain to return to their bondage;
 they not only proposed it, but determined upon it, which is reckoned the same as if they had done it, see ( Numbers 14:4 ) , 
 but thou art a God ready to pardon, gracious and merciful, slow to
 anger, and of great kindness;
 as he had proclaimed his name before Moses, and as the whole of his conduct towards the people of Israel abundantly shewed, see ( Exodus 34:6 Exodus 34:7 ) 
 and forsookest them not;
 when in the wilderness, where otherwise they must have perished, but still fed and protected them, notwithstanding their provocations.