Apostelgeschichte 5:39

39 wenn es aber aus Gott ist, so werdet ihr sie nicht zu Grunde richten können), damit ihr nicht gar als solche erfunden werdet, die wider Gott streiten.

Apostelgeschichte 5:39 Meaning and Commentary

Acts 5:39

But if it be of God
If it is according to the counsel of his will; if it is a scheme of his forming, and a work to which he has called these men, and they proceed in it on good principles, and with a view to the honour and glory of God:

ye cannot overthrow it;
it will proceed and get ground, and stand, maugre all the opposition of hell and earth; therefore do nothing to them, or hinder them from going on. Some copies read, "ye cannot overthrow them"; and add, "neither you, nor kings, nor tyrants; wherefore refrain from these men"; so Beza's Cambridge copy.

Lest haply ye be found even to fight against God;
which to do is downright madness, and which no man in his senses can expect to succeed in. There are some sayings of the Jewish doctors which seem to agree with these reasonings of Gamaliel ^F16.

``Says R. Jochanan the shoemaker, every congregation, which is for the name of heaven (or God) at length shall be established, but that which is not for the glory of God shall not be established in the end.''

Which one of the commentators ^F17 interprets in words still nearer to Gamaliel's language, thus:

``it shall be that that counsel which is for God shall stand and prosper, but that which is not for God shall cease.''

And in another place it is said ^F18,

``all contention (or dispute) which is for God, at length shall be established, but that which is not for God shall not in the end be established: what is contention that is for God? the contention of Hillell and Shammai, (two famous doctors among the Jews,) but that which is not for God is the contention of Korah, and his whole company.''

Some have thought from this advice of Gamaliel, that he was a Christian, or greatly inclined to Christianity; but when it is considered what respect was shown him at his death by the Jews, before observed on ( Acts 5:34 ) it will appear that he died a Pharisee; and especially it cannot be thought he had any favourable sentiments of the Christians, since a little before his death he ordered a prayer to be made against them. Maimonides says ^F19, that

``in the days of Rabban Gamaliel, the Epicureans (so the Amsterdam edition reads, but former editions read (Mynym) , "heretics", by whom are meant Christians) increased in Israel; and they distressed the Israelites, and seduced them to turn aside from God; and when he saw that this was greater than all the necessities of the children of men, he stood up, and his council or sanhedrim, and composed another prayer, in which there was a request to God to destroy the Epicureans,''

or heretics, meaning the Christians: and though this prayer is sometimes ascribed to Samuel the little, yet it was composed by him at the hint and instigation of Gamaliel; for so it is said ^F20, R. Gamaliel said to the wise men,

``is there no man that knows how to compose a prayer for the Sadducees? (R. Asher reads "heretics";) Samuel the little stood up and composed one.''

And it is also said ^F21, that

``Samuel the little composed, (Nynym tkrb) , "the prayer for the heretics", before, or in the presence of Gamaliel the elder.''

He made it when he was present, assisting, dictating, directing, and approving. The prayer was this ^F23,

``let there be no hope for apostates, and may all heretics perish in a moment, and all the enemies of thy people be quickly cut off: root out the kingdom of pride, and break, destroy, and subdue them in haste in our days.''

In some forms it is added,

``blessed art thou, O Lord, that breakest the wicked in pieces, and humblest the proud.''

Upon the whole, Gamaliel does not seem to have been a Christian, or to have favoured the Christian religion; but he was, as he is said, ( Acts 5:34 ) to be, a Pharisee: and this council, or sanhedrim, were, for the greater part of them, Sadducees, as seems from ( Acts 5:17 ) who, as the Jews say, were wicked and base men, men of very ill manners, whereas the Pharisees were (Mynmxr) , "merciful men" ^F24; and such an one was Gamaliel: he was a religious man in his way; a man of humanity, a mild and moderate man, that had compassion and pity for his fellow creatures; and could not give in to any schemes of cruelty and persecution, which the Sadducees were forward to; and upon these principles he acted, and upon these he gave this advice.

---

FOOTNOTES:

F16 Pirke Abot, c. 4 sect 11.
F17 Jarchi in ib.
F18 Pirke Abot, c. 5. sect. 17.
F19 Hilchot Tephilla, c. 2. sect. 1.
F20 T. Bab. Beracot, fol. 28. 2.
F21 Juchasin, fol. 21. 1. Ganz Tzemach David, par. 1. fol. 25. 2.
F23 Apud Buxtorf. Lex. Talmud. col. 2442. & Alting Shilo, l. 4. c. 26. p. 325.
F24 Juchasin, fol. 139. 1.

Apostelgeschichte 5:39 In-Context

37 Nach diesem stand Judas der Galiläer auf, in den Tagen der Einschreibung, und machte Volk abfällig sich nach; auch der kam um, und alle, so viele ihm Gehör gaben, wurden zerstreut.

38 Und jetzt sage ich euch: Stehet ab von diesen Menschen und lasset sie (denn wenn dieser Rat oder dieses Werk aus Menschen ist, so wird es zu Grunde gehen;

39 wenn es aber aus Gott ist, so werdet ihr sie nicht zu Grunde richten können), damit ihr nicht gar als solche erfunden werdet, die wider Gott streiten.

40 Und sie gaben ihm Gehör; und als sie die Apostel herbeigerufen hatten, schlugen sie sie und geboten ihnen, nicht in dem Namen Jesu zu reden, und entließen sie.

41 Sie nun gingen aus dem Synedrium hinweg, voll Freude, daß sie gewürdigt worden waren, für den Namen Schmach zu leiden;