Jean 4:11

11 La femme lui dit: Seigneur, tu n'as rien pour puiser, et le puits est profond; d'où aurais-tu donc cette eau vive?

Jean 4:11 Meaning and Commentary

John 4:11

The woman saith unto him, Sir
Which was an usual, way in those countries, of addressing men, and especially strangers; and expresses no uncommon respect to Christ, of whose dignity and greatness she was, entirely ignorant; and at whom she was now scoffing; for so the following words are to be understood:

thou hast nothing to draw with;
no pail, or bucket, or rope, to let it down with, as Nonnus adds; for it seems, there was no bucket, or vessel, fastened at the well for the common use, but everyone brought one with them, when they came to draw: though it is strange there was not one; since, according to common usage, and even of the Jews ^F21,

``a public well had, (lwq) , "a bucket", or pitcher; but a private well had no bucket:''

and the well is deep;
that which is now called Jacob's well, is by some said to be forty cubits deep, and by others thirty five yards:

from whence then hast thou that living water?
this she said in a sneering, scoffing manner: she reasoned with him, either that he must have it out of this well; but that could not be, since he had no vessel to draw with, and the well was so deep, that he could not come at the water without one; or he must have it from some neighbouring spring; upon which she scoffs at him in the following manner.

---

FOOTNOTES:

F21 T. Hieros. Erubin, fol. 20. 2.

Jean 4:11 In-Context

9 La femme samaritaine lui répondit: Comment, toi qui es Juif, me demandes-tu à boire, à moi qui suis une femme samaritaine? (Car les Juifs n'ont point de communication avec les Samaritains. )

10 Jésus répondit et lui dit: Si tu connaissais le don de Dieu, et qui est celui qui te dit: Donne-moi à boire, tu lui demanderais toi-même, et il te donnerait de l'eau vive.

11 La femme lui dit: Seigneur, tu n'as rien pour puiser, et le puits est profond; d'où aurais-tu donc cette eau vive?

12 Es-tu plus grand que Jacob notre père, qui nous a donné ce puits, et qui en a bu lui-même, ainsi que ses fils et ses troupeaux?

13 Jésus lui répondit: Quiconque boit de cette eau aura encore soif;