1 Samuel 2:24

24 Nicht, meine Kinder, das ist nicht ein gutes Gerücht, das ich höre. Ihr macht des HERRN Volk übertreten. {~}

1 Samuel 2:24 Meaning and Commentary

1 Samuel 2:24

Nay, my sons
This seems to be too soft and smooth an appellation, too kind and endearing, considering the offence they were guilty of, and were now reproving for; rather they deserved to be called sons of Belial, the children of the devil, than sons of Eli, or brutes and shameless wretches, and such like hard names:

for it is no good report that I hear;
a very bad one; far from being good, scarce anything worse could have been said of them; to rob persons of the flesh of their offerings, when there was a sufficient allowance made for them by law, and to be so impious as to require what was not their due, and even before the Lord had his; and to debauch the women that came to religious worship, and that in the sacred place of worship, they also being priests of the Lord, and married men; sins very shocking and sadly aggravated, and yet Eli treats them in this gentle manner:

ye make the Lord's people to transgress:
by causing them to forbear to bring their sacrifices, being used in such an injurious and overbearing way; and by decoying the women into uncleanness, and by setting examples to others: or, "to cry out"; as in the margin of our Bibles, to exclaim against them for their exorbitant and lewd practices; so the Targum,

``the people of the Lord murmur because so ill used by them:''

this clause may be read in connection with the former, "it is no good report that I hear, which ye cause to pass through the Lord's people"; ye occasion the people to speak ill of you everywhere, in the camp of Israel, throughout the whole nation; the report as it is bad, it is general, is in everyone's mouth; so Maimonides ^F21 interprets it; with which Jarchi and others agree ^F23.

---

FOOTNOTES:

F21 Moreh Nevochim, par. 1. c. 21.
F23 Vid. T. Bab. Sabbat, fol. 55. 2. & praefat. Ben Chayim. ad Bib. Heb. Bomberg. & Buxtorf.

1 Samuel 2:24 In-Context

22 Eli aber war sehr alt und erfuhr alles, was seine Söhne taten dem ganzen Israel, und daß sie schliefen bei den Weibern, die da dienten vor der Tür der Hütte des Stifts.

23 Und er sprach zu ihnen: Warum tut ihr solches? Denn ich höre euer böses Wesen von diesem ganzen Volk. {~}

24 Nicht, meine Kinder, das ist nicht ein gutes Gerücht, das ich höre. Ihr macht des HERRN Volk übertreten. {~}

25 Wenn jemand wider einen Menschen sündigt, so kann's der Richter schlichten. Wenn aber jemand wider den HERRN sündigt, wer kann für ihn bitten? Aber sie gehorchten ihres Vaters Stimme nicht; denn der HERR war willens, sie zu töten.

26 Aber der Knabe Samuel nahm immermehr zu und war angenehm bei dem HERRN und bei den Menschen. {~}